ISS Releases Guidance on Revised Peer Group Selection Methodology

As discussed in our recent Thoughtful Pay Alert on Institutional Shareholder Services’ updates to its U.S. corporate governance benchmark policy guidelines for 2013, ISS has revised its selection methodology for the peer group that it will use in assessing the alignment of a company’s executive compensation with corporate performance. One of these revisions gives greater weight to the company’s self-constructed compensation peer group. On December 4, 2012, ISS issued a series of “Frequently-Asked Questions” that provides details about how it intends to apply this revised methodology.

ISS will formulate updated peer groups using its revised methodology by early January 2013 to be applied when reviewing the executive compensation programs of companies with Annual Meetings of Shareholders occurring on or after February 1, 2013.

ISS is currently inviting companies to submit their self-constructed compensation peer groups for consideration in advance of this process. Note that this opportunity is only relevant for companies that have updated their compensation peer group since their last proxy statement filing and is intended to ensure that ISS is considering the relevant peer companies in terms of industry, size (that is, revenue and market capitalization), and other key factors when updating the peer group that will be used in its analysis.

If you want to provide ISS with updated compensation peer group information, you can submit this information to ISS using a form that identifies the constituent-companies in the self-constructed compensation peer group that you used in setting the compensation of your chief executive officer for the fiscal year that will be the subject of your next proxy statement filing. ISS has indicated that it will consider this information when formulating its updated peer group. You can find additional information, including detailed instructions on this submission process, at the following link: www.issgovernance.com/PeerFeedbackUS.

Note that, to take advantage of this opportunity, you must submit your compensation peer group information to ISS by December 21, 2012. Following submission, you will receive further instructions via e-mail (including confirmation of the submission) and be asked to provide an electronic copy of the peer group information on your company’s letterhead.

Please contact your Compensia engagement manager with any questions on the suitability of this submission for your company and for further assistance.

Download a pdf of this article »

Related

At an Inflection Point: Long-Term Incentive Design Post-ISS/Glass Lewis Ascendancy

Download a pdf of this article » For more than a decade, long-term incentive programs have largely converged around a single model: a mix of restricted stock units (RSUs) and performance-based awards (primarily PSUs), with 50% or higher weighting on the PSUs. The convergence on this model was driven more by proxy advisor expectations than business strategy. Two recent developments signal a major shift toward flexibility and innovation: ISS Policy Updates: ISS’s 2026 benchmark equity mix policy now recognizes that

Read More

Updating Proxy Advisor Peer Groups Ahead of 2026 Annual Meetings

Download a pdf of this article » For companies holding annual meetings February 1, 2026 through September 15, 2026, ISS’s peer group submission window is now open, through 8 PM ET on Friday, November 21st. We anticipate Glass Lewis’s window will also open in the near future. During this period, companies can update their self-constructed compensation peer groups for use in proxy advisors’ upcoming executive pay assessments. Absent a submission, both ISS and Glass Lewis will default to the peer

Read More

Have we reached the end of standardized proxy advisor voting recommendations? The looming ISS and Glass Lewis policy shifts

Download a pdf of this article » Overview In October, Institutional Shareholder Services, Inc. (“ISS”) and Glass Lewis & Co., Inc. (“Glass Lewis”) each announced major changes to their governance research models that mark a decisive shift away from standardized “benchmark” voting recommendations, towards a broad reorientation of the proxy advisor landscape centered on investor-specific customization – a change that is consistent with investors’ diversifying views regarding compensation program design that have led to questioning legacy views regarding the effectiveness

Read More

Glass Lewis Publishes 2025 Policy Survey

Download a pdf of this article » Glass Lewis & Co. (“Glass Lewis”) recently announced the opening of its 2025 Policy Survey. Glass Lewis conducts its annual policy survey to inform its Benchmark Voting Policy Guidelines and to gather diverse perspectives on evolving governance and compensation practices. The 2025 survey covers a wide range of topics relevant to both proxy voting and broader stewardship efforts. While some questions are tailored to institutional respondents, Glass Lewis welcomes input from all market

Read More

Connect with us

Receive our periodic news and publications

"*" indicates required fields

Name*

By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive emails from us. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact